200+
New followers gained
01Challenge
A Birmingham boutique retailer had built a loyal in-store customer base but was struggling to translate that loyalty into a growing social media presence. Engagement rates were inconsistent, content output was high-effort but low-return, and competitors were steadily gaining ground online.
02Analysis
We audited the client's social media performance across 90 days: post types, timing, engagement rates, and audience growth trends. We benchmarked performance against five direct local competitors and three analogous national brands. Simultaneously, we analyzed the client's highest-performing content to identify the attributes that drove outsized engagement.
03Insight
The client's best-performing content had a consistent pattern: it featured specific products in context (styled, in use, or behind-the-scenes), rather than polished product photography. Audience interaction spiked on conversational captions and dropped on promotional ones. Competitors were posting more frequently but with lower engagement per post, indicating an opportunity to compete on quality rather than volume.
04Recommendation
We delivered a content strategy framework prioritizing three post formats with documented performance advantages, a revised posting cadence based on the client's own audience activity data, and a competitive differentiation brief identifying two content whitespace opportunities that no local competitor was occupying.
05Impact
Following implementation of the recommendations, the client gained over 200 new social media followers, representing a meaningful step in building an owned audience and reducing dependence on paid reach.
Relative engagement by content type, pre-engagement analysis